Isoniazid vs Alternative TB Drugs: Detailed Comparison

Isoniazid vs Alternative TB Drugs: Detailed Comparison
Kevin Richter Oct, 5 2025

TB Drug Comparison Tool

Side Effects Overview

Drug Common Side Effects Serious Risks
Isoniazid Transient nausea, headache, peripheral neuropathy Hepatotoxicity, severe liver injury
Rifampin Orange body fluids, mild GI upset Hepatotoxicity, strong inducer of CYP450
Ethambutol Blurred vision, rash Optic neuritis leading to permanent vision loss if untreated
Pyrazinamide Gout flares, nausea Severe hepatotoxicity, hyperuricemia
Bedaquiline QT prolongation, nausea Cardiac arrhythmia, hepatotoxicity
Delamanid Headache, dizziness QT prolongation, hepatic dysfunction

When treating active tuberculosis, Isoniazid is a first‑line oral antibiotic that blocks mycolic acid synthesis in Mycobacterium tuberculosis. It’s been a cornerstone of TB therapy since the 1950s, but clinicians often wonder whether another drug might work better for a particular patient. This article walks through the most common alternatives, points out where each shines, and helps you decide which regimen fits a given clinical picture.

What makes Isoniazid a go‑to drug?

Isoniazid (INH) is prized for three reasons:

  • High early bactericidal activity - it rapidly reduces the bacterial load in the first two weeks of therapy.
  • Simple once‑daily dosing - most adults take 300mg (or weight‑based 5mg/kg) in a single daily tablet.
  • Low cost - generic versions are typically under ÂŁ1 per month in the UK.

Its downsides include liver toxicity, especially in older adults or those drinking alcohol, and a risk of peripheral neuropathy that can be mitigated with vitamin B6 supplementation.

Key alternatives to consider

Below are the main drugs you’ll see paired with or swapped for Isoniazid in modern regimens.

Rifampin is a broad‑spectrum antibiotic that inhibits RNA synthesis in Mycobacterium tuberculosis. It’s usually given at 600mg daily for adults and is essential in both standard 6‑month regimens and shorter 4‑month protocols.

Ethambutol works by disrupting cell‑wall formation and is given at 15mg/kg daily. It’s added mainly to prevent resistance when susceptibility is unknown.

Pyrazinamide is a pro‑drug that becomes active in acidic environments, targeting dormant bacilli. The typical adult dose is 20-25mg/kg daily for the first two months of treatment.

Streptomycin is an injectable aminoglycoside that interferes with protein synthesis. It’s reserved for multi‑drug‑resistant (MDR) cases or when oral options are limited.

Bedaquiline is a newer diarylquinoline that inhibits the ATP synthase of Mycobacterium tuberculosis. Approved for MDR‑TB, it’s dosed 400mg daily for two weeks, then three times per week.

Delamanid is a nitro‑imidazole that blocks mycolic acid synthesis, similar to Isoniazid but with a different enzymatic target. Used in MDR‑TB, the adult dose is 100mg twice daily.

Each alternative brings its own side‑effect profile, drug‑interaction concerns, and cost considerations.

Side‑effect snapshot

Common side‑effects of Isoniazid and its alternatives
Drug Typical Side‑effects Serious Risks
Isoniazid Transient nausea, headache, peripheral neuropathy Hepatotoxicity, severe liver injury
Rifampin Orange body fluids, mild GI upset Hepatotoxicity, strong inducer of CYP450 (affects many meds)
Ethambutol Blurred vision, rash Optic neuritis leading to permanent vision loss if untreated
Pyrazinamide Gout flares, nausea Severe hepatotoxicity, hyperuricemia
Streptomycin Injection site pain Ototoxicity, nephrotoxicity
Bedaquiline QT prolongation, nausea Cardiac arrhythmia, hepatotoxicity
Delamanid Headache, dizziness QT prolongation, hepatic dysfunction

Drug‑interaction landscape

Understanding interactions helps avoid treatment failures. Isoniazid is a mild inhibitor of CYP2C19 and CYP3A4, meaning it can raise levels of certain antiretrovirals and anticonvulsants. Rifampin, on the other hand, is a potent CYP450 inducer, slashing concentrations of warfarin, oral contraceptives, and many HIV drugs. Bedaquiline and Delamanid share QT‑prolonging potential, so they should never be combined with other QT‑extending agents like fluoroquinolones without close ECG monitoring.

When to choose Isoniazid versus an alternative

When to choose Isoniazid versus an alternative

Here’s a quick decision guide:

  1. Newly diagnosed drug‑susceptible TB - Standard 6‑month regimen (INH+Rifampin+Ethambutol+Pyrazinamide) works for >95% of patients.
  2. High risk of liver disease - Replace INH with Rifampin‑only intensive phase, add Streptomycin if resistance is a concern.
  3. Known INH resistance - Use Rifampin+Ethambutol+Pyrazinamide, consider adding Fluoroquinolone (e.g., Levofloxacin) for a longer intensive phase.
  4. MDR‑TB (resistant to INH and Rifampin) - Build a regimen with Bedaquiline, Delamanid, a later‑generation Fluoroquinolone, and an injectable like Streptomycin.
  5. Pregnancy - Isoniazid is generally safe; Rifampin is also acceptable. Avoid Streptomycin due to ototoxicity risk to the fetus.

These scenarios illustrate that Isoniazid remains valuable, but the right choice balances resistance patterns, patient comorbidities, and drug‑accessibility.

Monitoring and follow‑up

For anyone on Isoniazid, baseline liver function tests (ALT/AST) are a must, with repeat testing at month 1 and month 2. Patients over 35years or those consuming alcohol regularly need more frequent checks. Vitamin B6 (pyridoxine) 25mg daily prevents neuropathy in high‑risk groups. With Rifampin, monitor for drug‑level drops of co‑prescribed meds. Bedaquiline and Delamanid require baseline and monthly ECGs to watch QT intervals.

Cost and accessibility snapshot

In the UK, Isoniazid and Rifampin are funded under the NHS TB program, making them essentially free for patients. Ethambutol and Pyrazinamide are similarly covered. Bedaquiline and Delamanid are newer and can be pricey (≈£1,200‑£1,500 for a full course), but they’re available through specialty pharmacies for MDR‑TB cases.

Bottom line: the Isoniazid comparison you needed

If you’re dealing with standard, drug‑susceptible TB, Isoniazid stays the cheapest, most effective backbone. When liver health is shaky, resistance looms, or the disease is multi‑drug‑resistant, you’ll need to lean on Rifampin, Ethambutol, or the newer agents. Always pair the drug choice with the right monitoring plan, and remember that drug interactions can make or break a regimen.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I take Isoniazid with alcohol?

Occasional light drinking is generally tolerated, but heavy or chronic alcohol use dramatically raises the risk of liver injury. If you drink more than two units a day, discuss liver‑function monitoring with your doctor.

Why is vitamin B6 given with Isoniazid?

Isoniazid can deplete pyridoxine, leading to peripheral neuropathy. A daily 25mg dose of pyridoxine prevents numbness and tingling, especially in diabetics and pregnant women.

What makes Bedaquiline different from Isoniazid?

Bedaquiline targets ATP synthase, a distinct bacterial enzyme, giving it activity against strains resistant to Isoniazid and Rifampin. It’s reserved for MDR‑TB and requires cardiac monitoring.

Is it safe to use Isoniazid during pregnancy?

Yes, most guidelines list Isoniazid as safe in all trimesters, provided pyridoxine supplementation is given. It helps prevent congenital TB, which can be fatal.

How long does a typical Isoniazid course last?

For latent TB infection, a 6‑month daily regimen (INH+pyridoxine) is common. For active disease, Isoniazid is part of a 6‑month combination therapy, with the drug given throughout.

4 Comments

  • Image placeholder

    Andrea Dunn

    October 5, 2025 AT 02:17

    They don't want you to know the real side effects 😒

  • Image placeholder

    Sunthar Sinnathamby

    October 8, 2025 AT 02:46

    Balancing the efficacy of isoniazid with its hepatotoxic risk is crucial. In standard TB cases, the drug’s early bactericidal activity saves lives. However, you must watch liver enzymes closely, especially in patients over 35 or with alcohol use. Adding pyridoxine can prevent peripheral neuropathy, a simple yet often overlooked step. The regimen’s low cost makes it unbeatable for most health systems. Stay vigilant, and you’ll keep the cure effective.

  • Image placeholder

    Catherine Mihaljevic

    October 11, 2025 AT 03:15

    Isoniazid works but it’s not a miracle drug it can wreck the liver if you’re not careful

  • Image placeholder

    Callum Smyth

    October 14, 2025 AT 03:45

    Great rundown! 👍 Remember to schedule monthly liver function tests and keep pyridoxine handy – it’s a small step that prevents big problems. If a patient shows any jaundice, pause the therapy and re‑evaluate. Keep the communication open with the care team and the patient – that’s how you stay ahead of side‑effects.

Write a comment